A genuine redundancy occurs where the position ceases to exist and the employee is not replaced. Where that is not what happened, other rules apply.
The three failures
A redundancy is unfair if:
- It was not a genuine redundancy situation
- The selection for redundancy was discriminatory or unfair
- Proper procedures were not followed
Any of the three grounds an unfair dismissal claim at the WRC.
The automatic case
A redundancy connected to your pregnancy or maternity leave is automatically unfair.
No further test applies.
Being replaced
If your employer makes you redundant and then hires someone else to do the exact same job shortly after, that may be unfair dismissal rather than redundancy — the job itself must have gone.
The procedural requirements
Meaningful individual consultation is mandatory for every redundancy, including:
- A risk letter
- A meeting to discuss alternatives
Employers must use objective, measurable selection criteria and document the rationale to avoid discrimination and unfair dismissal claims.